Vintage molecular / atomic / ionic models. A resource on selected major makers with documents. Biobits, Catalin Ionic and Covalent, Cochranes of Oxford (Open University), Ealing Corey-Pauling-Koltun (CPK), Courtauld, Fisher-Hirschfeld-Taylor (FHT), Gallenkamp, Sargent. by David Walker, UK
Image right (click for larger), Catalin Ionic showing NaCl, |
Aim and Scope Before the wide availability of powerful and affordable computers, modeling covalent molecules and ionic structures by researchers was primarily with physical models. Such kits are still widely available primarily for students (see review of some major makers in refs.) but even in the educational role, software for many reasons is becoming more dominant.
Vintage modeling systems by a variety of makers are very collectable with some makers now long gone*. Such systems when sold e.g. on eBay or by auction houses do not always come with manuals and brochures. The author has a small collection of these older kits and has endeavoured to track down paper resources to accompany them. The systems below give links to download pdf copies of resources acquired or to links where they are available online.
* The definitive resource on these systems is Molecular and Crystal Structure Models by Anne Walton, pub. 1978 by Ellis Horwood Ltd., 201 pp. See Books below.
Initially, short summary tables of the kits are given but below but in due course it is hoped to devote pages to examples of model types that can be built with the author's comments on each kit's pros and cons. The BioBits model type described is suited for some smaller macromolecules. With enough pieces some of the other makes described are also suitable and dedicated kits are available to build a short length of DNA eg. the Orbit and Minit kits. See author's review of the Minit Proview DNA kit.
Note on dating. The exact date when a kit
was first issued and its production run can be hard to
determine unless the often hard to source maker's dated
catalogues can be inspected. All the kits below were
described in Anne Walton's definitive book published in 1978
and which is a primary reference for many of the design
elements.
Images of the sets are
clickable for larger versions.
Biobits
Maker / designer |
Own example supplied by Philip Harris Biological Ltd. / Invented by Dr. Ivor Smith, Courtauld Institute of Biochemistry, UK (Walton, p.127 ff). |
Type |
Custom design to create macromolecular backbones of nucleic acids / proteins and can present tertiary structures. |
Materials |
Thick copper wire with coloured PVC collars with attachable colour coded purine and pyrimidine bases using 'poppet style heads'. |
Presentation |
Plastic box with compartments. |
Scale |
30 mm = 0.2 nm |
|
![]() |
|
|
Documents:
|
Biobits Nucleic Acid (BN) General Notes to Accompany all Kits. A five page typed A4 supplement was also included in my own purchased outfit. |
Catalin Ionic
Maker / designer |
Needs Plastics Ld, Middlesex, UK. The company still exists with a website and makes custom plastic items. |
Type |
Ionic |
Materials |
Catalin, a brand name for a
phenol-formaldehyde plastic, see Wikipedia entry for 'Catalin'. Anions translucent,
cations opaque. |
Presentation |
Wooden box with compartments. |
Scale |
10 mm = 0.1 nm |
|
![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
|
Documents:
|
(*Acknowledgement. Thank you to Bill an eBay UK seller ID 'chemistry63hg' now 'Neutrino Positive' who sold me my example. A fellow passionate collector of vintage models who loaned these original documents to scan from the second kit he possessed.) |
Catalin Molecular
Maker / designer |
Needs Plastics Ld, Middlesex, UK. The company still exists with a website and makes custom plastic items. |
Type |
Covalent, space filling |
Materials |
Catalin, a brand name for a phenol-formaldehyde plastic, see Wikipedia entry for 'Catalin'. Anions translucent, cations opaque. |
Presentation |
Wooden box with compartments. |
Scale |
10 mm = 0.1 nm |
|
|
|
|
Documents:
|
(*Acknowledgement. Thank you to Bill an eBay UK seller ID 'chemistry63hg' now 'Neutrino Positive' who sold me my example. A fellow passionate collector of vintage models who loaned these original documents to scan from the second kit he possessed.) |
Courtauld
Ealing CPK (Corey - Pauling - Koltun)
Maker / Designer |
Ealing, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA. / 'Sub-committee of the U.S National Institutes of Health' (Walton, p.41) |
Type |
Space filling |
Materials |
Hollow coloured plastic |
Presentation |
Compartmentalised box? |
Scale |
12.5 mm = 0.1 nm |
|
Kit images - (The author does not currently own an example of this set.) |
|
|
Documents:
|
See references on the Wikipedia 'Space-filling model' page to
papers by the designers. |
Fisher-Hirschfeld-Taylor (FHT)
Maker / Designer |
Fisher Scientific Co, USA. A long established from the 1880s laboratory supplier and of scientific apparatus. See the history on the company's current website. |
Type |
Space filling |
Materials |
Coloured hollow plastic atoms with 'press stud' style metal bond fastenings. |
Presentation |
Wooden box with compartments. |
Scale |
10 mm = 0.1 nm |
|
|
|
|
Documents:
|
Kit image above temporary from my recent eBay purchase pending receipt. |
Gallenkamp
Maker / Designer |
Gallenkamp, UK. A long established from the 1880s laboratory supplier and of scientific apparatus. See the history on the company's current website. |
Type |
Ball and spoke |
Materials |
Coloured plastic balls with drilled holes for multiple valencies. Steel spring bonds. |
Presentation |
Cabinet with drawers for largest set, plastic boxes for smaller sets (see catalogue scan below). |
Scale |
35 mm = 0.1 nm (to atom centres) |
|
|
|
|
Documents:
|
|
Cochranes of Oxford. Orbit Open University
Sargent
Maker / Designer |
E H Sargent & Co., Chicago. The company was established in 1852 with a long history in supplying laboratory and scientific equipment, after a merger in 1968 becoming the Sargent-Welch Scientific Company. The link is to the current Sargent-Welch website. |
Type |
Ball and spoke |
Materials |
Painted wooden balls with slotted wooden pegs and springs. |
Presentation |
Cardboard box with compartments. |
Scale |
C & N atoms 11⁄4 inch diameter, others 11⁄8 th inch diameter. |
|
|
|
|
Documents:
|
The booklet notes that it was '"Derived from "Molecular Models in the Elementary Organic Laboratory" by Wallace R. Brode and Cecil E. Boord, Journal of Chemical Education, 9,1774, (1932).' (Open Access on the archive.org site.) |
Books
Molecular and Crystal Structure Models by Anne Walton, pub. 1978 by Ellis Horwood
Ltd., 201 pp.
This is the key resource on models by
all the key makers, written in 1978 when physical models still
dominated with wide access to computer modelling software some
decades away. At the time of writing two copies are available
on AbeBooks starting below £10. The passion of the writer
for her subject shines through and a good read.
The publisher's note on the author is quoted as follows.
Dr. Anne Walton is Senior Lecturer in
Chemistry at Westfield College, University of London. She
joined the College initially in 1961 from the University
of Aberdeen, where she had been Assistant in Chemistry.
Dr. Walton gained her B.Sc. and Ph.D. in Chemistry from
the University of Nottingham in 1957 and 1960
respectively.
Her pre-university career began in 1948, when she joined
the Research Association, British Rubber Manufacturers as
a laboratory assistant. From 1952 to 1954 she was
laboratory assistant at Beckenham County Grammar School
for Girls, Kent, simultaneously studying part-time at
Croydon and Norwood Polytechnics for her university
entrance qualifications.
The author is highly-esteemed in the field of molecular
and crystal structure models, having lectured and
demonstrated on models and their applications at the
Universities of Loughborough, Nottingham, East Anglia and
the University of London Institute of Education, and
mounted full-scale exhibitions at Westfield College and at
the University of Sheffield for The Chemical Society
Autumn Meetings, 1976. James Gillison's cover design shows
a guanine-cystosine base pair model.
The Architecture of Molecules by Linus Pauling and Roger Hayward, pub. 1964 by Freeman, 117pp.
An author who needs no introduction. A superb book aimed at the general audience celebrating the variety of chemical structures. Full page artwork by Hayward with opposite page text by Pauling. Copies currently available on AbeBooks starting below £10, also often eBay.
Sinnbild der Chemie, Microstructures of Chemistry, Les microstructures chimiques by Herbert W Franke, pub. 1967 by Basilius Presse AG, 148pp.
This is a splendid celebration of chemical structures with an extensive introduction in German followed by full page illustrations of structures using both physical and computer methods. The image captions are in English and French as well as German.
Phone app software such as Yandex Translate is very useful to translate to screen part pages to read quite comfortably. Two copies currently on AbeBooks from £23.
Other Micscape resources
I've attempted a review for five of the main
molecular models systems presently available.
A comparative review
of five brands of molecular model kits. With notes on the
educational merits of kits in an age of software. - compares five current major brands
(ChemKits, Minit, Molecular Visions (Darling Models),
Molymod, Orbit)
with 'Molecules in the News' in
Spring 2017 supplement (heptacene, triangulene and a
molecular
machine (a molecular ratchet). PDFs Apr.17
Combining my interest in stamps some past articles present models of molecules from Nature both goodies and nasties. See Micscape Lite section.
Selection of online resources
Whipple Museum of the History of Science (Cambridge, UK) Types of Molecular Models. Describes the basic types with examples from their collection.
Wikipedia 'Molecular model' entry. A short history with discussion of
types, Further Reading and links to online resources.
The History of Molecular Models link in the
Wikipedia entry above is to an illustrated 2004 paper entitled
'Visualizing the Unseen' by W. Gerhard Pohl. This is a new
reference to the author and a good read. (Link is to a
Wayback Machine mirror, the conference website it was
presented at no longer exists.)
History of Visualization of Biological Macromolecules by Eric Martz and Francoeur. Extensive website resource. Includes both physical and computer model approaches.
Comments to the author David Walker are welcomed.
Published in the November 2024 edition of Micscape.
Please report any errors to the Micscape Magazine Editor via the contact on current magazine index.
Micscape Magazine is the free monthly web magazine of Microscopy-UK.
© Onview.net Ltd, Microscopy-UK, and all contributors 1995 onwards. All rights reserved.